Leak or condensation
Before anyone touches the roof, figure out whether water is coming in from outside or forming on the inside. A skylight is a piece of glass or plastic set into the roof, and its inside face is often the coolest surface in the room. In a Florida house with humid air inside, that surface can sweat.
Condensation shows up as beads or a film on the inside of the glazing, and it drips from the lowest point of the frame. It often appears on cool mornings, whether or not it has rained. A leak follows the weather. It shows up during or after rain, and it is usually worse with wind from one direction.
Bathrooms and kitchens are the usual places for condensation, because that is where the moisture is. A bathroom fan that does not vent outside, or is never run, makes it worse. That is a ventilation problem, not a roof problem, and no flashing work will fix it.
If you cannot tell, wipe the glazing and the light well dry and check the next morning with no rain in between. Water that came back without rain did not come through the roof.
Curb-mounted and deck-mounted skylights
There are two common ways a skylight sits on a roof. A curb-mounted skylight sits on a short box frame built up off the deck, usually out of lumber, and the unit fits over the top of it. A deck-mounted skylight fastens straight to the roof deck by its own flange, and it is usually sold with a matching flashing kit from the manufacturer.
They fail in slightly different places. On a curb-mounted unit, the curb is a small wall sticking out of the roof, and it has to be flashed like one, on all four sides. On a deck-mounted unit, the flange and the factory kit do that job, and the kit only works if it went in with the parts and in the order the manufacturer specifies.
Older homes here often have curb-mounted units, sometimes on curbs built on site and flashed with whatever was on the truck. Knowing which kind you have tells us what the flashing is supposed to look like, and how far what is there now is from it.
Failed seal or failed flashing
A skylight has two separate jobs. The unit has to keep water out between the glazing and its frame. The flashing has to keep water out between the frame and the roof. When people say the skylight leaks, they usually mean the first. Most of the time it is the second.
A failed seal in the unit shows up in the unit. On a double-glazed skylight, fog trapped between the two panes means the seal between them has gone. That does not usually drip into the room, but it does mean the unit is getting old. Water coming in at the joint between glazing and frame, with the outside of the curb dry, also points to the unit.
Failed flashing looks different. Water runs down the outside of the curb or the light well, stains the drywall in the shaft, or shows up at a corner. Look at where the staining is. Water at the top or the upslope corners almost always means flashing, not glass.
The top of the curb is where most water actually gets in. Every drop that runs down the roof above the skylight hits that curb and has to be turned around it. The head flashing carries it sideways. The step flashing on each side passes it down, one piece per course, lapped under the shingles. If the head flashing is short, bent or missing, or the step flashing was replaced with one long strip and caulk, that is where the leak starts.
Every drop that runs down the roof above a skylight hits the top of the curb first. That is where most skylight leaks start, not in the glass.
Sealant around the edge, and old acrylic domes
The fix we see most is a bead of sealant or roofing cement run around the whole skylight. It looks tidy, and sometimes it stops the drip for a season. It does not fix anything. The water was getting past the flashing, and the sealant only covers where it showed. When it shrinks and cracks in the sun, and it will, water gets behind it and sits against the curb with no way to dry. That rots the curb faster.
Sealant also hides the problem from the next person who looks. A skylight with three layers of cement around it tells us someone has been chasing a flashing leak for a while. The real repair is to lift the shingles around the curb and rebuild the head flashing, the step flashing and the apron at the bottom, in the right order, each piece lapped so water runs over it and not behind it.
The old acrylic bubble skylights on many older Florida homes are a separate problem. Acrylic does not stand up to UV the way glass does. Once a dome has been in the sun fifteen or twenty years, it is common to see it turn yellow and cloudy and develop a web of fine cracks called crazing. A crazed dome is brittle. It can crack through in a storm or under a falling branch, and then no flashing work matters.
If your dome is yellowed and crazed, the unit is near the end, whatever the flashing is doing. We will tell you that instead of building new flashing around an old dome.
Replace the skylight when the roof comes off
The sensible time to replace a skylight is when the roof around it comes off. The shingles are already gone, the curb and the decking around it are exposed, and the new flashing goes in with the new underlayment as one job. The skylight and the roof around it start out the same age.
Replacing a skylight on a roof that stays means cutting into sound roofing and blending new shingles into old ones. It can be done well, but it rarely matches, and it puts new flashing against older roofing that will be torn off before the skylight is worn out.
If your roof is due and the skylight is an old acrylic dome or a unit with failed seals, that is the time to decide. You can replace it, or remove it and deck over the opening if you no longer want it. Either is simpler during a replacement than at any other time.
For insurance, we photograph what we find and put the condition of the roof and the skylight in writing. We do not perform or sign wind mitigation or four-point inspections, because a roofing license does not qualify under Florida Statute 627.711(2). We do not know how your carrier will treat a leak or an old skylight. That is between you and your carrier.
