352-830-0756 Serving all of Citrus County Licensed & Insured · FL CCC1333347

Guide

Should You Buy Your Own Roofing Materials?

Homeowners look up roofing suppliers because they assume the materials are where the money is. Here is where the materials on a normal job actually come from, the three things a homeowner-supplied order usually gets wrong, and why it changes who stands behind the roof.

Roofing materialsRoof warrantiesHiring a roofer

Where the materials on a normal job come from

On a normal reroof the homeowner never handles a bundle. The contractor measures the roof, writes a material list, and orders it from a roofing distributor. A distributor is a supply house that sells to roofers. It stocks the full systems from the main manufacturers, not just the shingles.

The order is usually delivered the day before tear-off or the morning of. On a shingle job the truck often has a boom that sets the bundles straight onto the roof, spread across the slopes so no one spot carries the whole load. Underlayment, flashing, vents, nails and the dumpster arrive on their own schedule.

Homeowners start looking up suppliers for an understandable reason. They see a quote, they see shingles on a shelf at a big-box store, and they assume the difference between the two is markup on material. Some of it is. Most of it is labor, disposal, the permit, insurance, and the parts of the roof that are not on that shelf at all.

The shingle is the part of the order a homeowner can see on a shelf. It is not most of what goes on the roof.

Why a contractor orders through a distributor and not a big-box store

A big-box store carries a narrow slice of roofing. Usually a few shingle colors from one or two lines, some felt or synthetic underlayment, a few boots and a bin of nails. A distributor carries the matched underlayment, starter, hip and ridge, ventilation and flashing for each shingle line it sells, and it can get the color you picked in the quantity the roof needs.

Every roofing product installed in Florida needs a product approval, and the permit lists what is going on the roof. A distributor that serves roofers knows which products carry approval for the way they will be installed. A homeowner reading a label in a store aisle often does not, and the inspector does not care where it was bought.

A contractor also has an account. Shortages get filled the same day. Damaged bundles get swapped. Unopened surplus goes back on the truck. None of that runs through a homeowner's receipt.

The three things a homeowner-supplied order usually gets wrong

The first is quantity. People measure the footprint of the house, or the area of each slope, and buy that much shingle. That leaves out waste from cuts at every hip, valley, wall and rake, and a roof with more of those wastes more. It also leaves out the starter strip along the eaves and rakes and the hip and ridge caps along the top. Those are separate products, sold separately, and a crew cannot finish a roof without them. Running short mid-job means a stopped crew and an open roof.

The second is a mismatched system. A shingle from one maker, underlayment from a second and starter from a third will all go on a roof. But manufacturers write their enhanced system warranties around their own components installed together. Mix the brands and the roof usually does not qualify for that system warranty. You are left with the basic product warranty on each piece, from different companies, each able to point at the others.

The third is surplus with no way back. A contractor's account can return unopened bundles to the distributor. A homeowner's leftovers, especially special-order colors or cut rolls, often have no return path at all. They end up in the garage, or in the dumpster at the end of the job.

There is a fourth that shows up less often but costs more. Material that sits in a Florida driveway for a week before the crew arrives takes sun and rain. Shingles stacked in the heat can stick together, and wet underlayment should not go on a roof.

What a manufacturer warranty covers and what the installer covers

A manufacturer warranty covers defects in the material. If the shingle itself fails because of how it was made, that is the manufacturer's problem, within the terms of the warranty document. It does not cover the way the shingle was nailed, flashed or ventilated.

The installer's workmanship warranty covers the installation. Leaks at flashing, lifted shingles from bad nailing, a missing kickout at a wall. Those are workmanship, and they are on the roofer who did the work. Most roof leaks are workmanship and detail problems, not material defects.

Manufacturers also write installation requirements into their warranties. Nail count and placement, the starter they require, the underlayment they accept, the ventilation they expect. If the installation does not meet those terms, the material warranty can be refused even when the shingle is fine. That is one reason the installer needs to know exactly what is going on the roof before the job starts.

Why nobody will warrant an installation over material they did not specify

When we write the material list, we are responsible for it being right. The right quantity, the right products for the permit, a system that qualifies for the manufacturer's warranty. If something is wrong, it is ours to fix. When a homeowner supplies the material, that responsibility does not move to us just because we nailed it down.

So a contractor installing homeowner-supplied material will usually warrant the labor only, if anything, and will write that limit into the contract. If a shingle you bought turns out to be defective, the claim is between you and the manufacturer. Tearing off and reinstalling it is not something the installer will carry for free. Some roofers will not install customer-supplied material at all for this reason.

None of this means buying your own materials is never done. It means the saving people expect is often smaller than it looks once the missing items, the surplus and the thinner warranty are counted. We do not know what your roof needs until we have been on it. Ask for the full material list in writing, with brand, product line and quantity for every item, and compare that instead of comparing shingle prices.

Straight answers

Common questions

Can I buy my own roofing materials and hire a roofer for labor only?

Some roofers will do it and some will not. The ones who do usually limit their warranty to labor, put that in writing, and leave any material claim between you and the manufacturer. Ask before you buy anything, because the roofer may also need to check the products against the permit.

Is it cheaper to buy roofing materials myself?

Sometimes the shingles look cheaper on a shelf than they do on a quote. The comparison usually leaves out waste, starter, hip and ridge, underlayment, flashing, vents and fasteners, and it leaves out what happens to the surplus. We do not give numbers before looking at a roof. Compare full written material lists, not the price of a bundle.

Does buying my own shingles void the manufacturer warranty?

The basic product warranty on the shingle usually still applies to the shingle. What tends to be lost is the enhanced system warranty, which manufacturers tie to their own matched components and to qualifying installers. If the underlayment, starter and ridge are from different makers, the roof usually will not qualify. Read the actual warranty document for the product you are considering.

Where does GenX Roofing get its materials?

From roofing distributors, the supply houses that sell to licensed roofers, delivered to the job. Before work starts you get the material list in writing, with the brand, product line and quantity of each item, so you know exactly what is going on your roof and which warranty it carries.

Where to go next

What we actually do

01

Roof Replacement

Architectural shingle, standing-seam metal and tile. Full tear-off, deck inspection, code-compliant rebuild.

View
02

Roof Repair

Cracked and lifted shingles, failed boots and flashing, ridge cap damage, nail pops and exposed fasteners.

View
03

Mobile Home Roofing

Seam and coating failure, ponding on low slopes, roof-overs, metal and TPO on manufactured homes.

View