The part you will never see again
Most homeowners judge a roof by the shingle, the tile or the metal. That is the last layer to go on and the only one you can see from the street. Under it sit the decking, the nails holding the decking down, one or two layers of water barrier, metal edging and flashing, and a starter course. Every one of those is covered up by the end of the first day or two.
Once the covering is on, nobody checks those layers again until the roof is torn off. Not you, not the next buyer, and often not the inspector, who sees parts of the work but not every nail and every lap. That is exactly why corners get cut there. A missing piece of step flashing or a sheet of rotten decking left in place does not show on the finished roof. It shows years later as a leak or a soft spot.
So when you compare quotes, the shingle brand is the least useful thing on the page. What matters is what each contractor says they will do underneath it, and whether they put it in writing.
The layers that decide how long a roof lasts are the ones nobody looks at again once the covering goes on.
Decking, nailing and the secondary water barrier
The decking is the wood the whole roof is fastened to. On most Florida homes it is plywood or OSB sheathing nailed to the rafters or trusses. Older homes sometimes have plank decking instead. When the old roof comes off, the decking should be walked and checked. Soft, rotten or delaminated sheets get cut out and replaced. Covering bad decking with new shingles is one of the most common shortcuts, and once the shingles are on you cannot tell.
How the decking is nailed matters as much as what it is. In a hurricane, wind pulls up on the roof, and the decking is what the roof covering hangs on. The Florida Building Code sets the nail type and spacing for reroofs, and on older homes that often means re-nailing the existing deck with ring-shank nails before anything else goes down. Ask whether that is in the quote. It is quick to do with the roof open and impossible to do after.
On top of the decking goes the secondary water barrier. It is a self-adhered membrane, either as strips over the seams between sheets or covering the whole deck. Its job is to keep water out of the house if the covering and the underlayment are torn off in a storm. The code calls for it on many reroofs, and we check whether yours needs it before the permit is pulled.
Deck nailing and a secondary water barrier are both items that can appear on a wind mitigation form. We do not perform or sign wind mitigation or four-point inspections, because a roofing license does not qualify under Florida Statute 627.711(2). What we do is document what was installed, with photographs, so the inspector you hire has something to look at.
Underlayment, drip edge and starter course
Underlayment is the layer between the deck and the covering. For a long time that meant asphalt-saturated felt. Today most shingle roofs here get a synthetic underlayment, a woven or spun plastic sheet, and tile and metal roofs often get a self-adhered membrane rated for high temperatures.
What a synthetic upgrade buys in Florida heat is mostly durability. Felt absorbs moisture, wrinkles when it gets wet and dries out over time, and under a hot roof it can turn brittle. Synthetic does not soak up water, lies flat, tears less underfoot and holds up better if it sits exposed for a day or two before the covering goes on. Under tile, where the underlayment is often what actually fails, the choice of underlayment matters more than the tile. It does not make a roof leak-proof. It makes the second line of defense more likely to still be working when the first one fails.
Drip edge is the bent metal strip along the eaves and the rakes. It carries water off the roof edge and into the gutter instead of letting it wick back onto the fascia and the deck edge. At the eaves it goes under the underlayment. At the rakes it goes over it. Getting that order backward sends water behind the metal instead of over it.
The starter course is the first row along the eaves and rakes, laid under the first full course of shingles. A proper starter strip has a sealant line right at the edge, so the edge of the roof is glued down. That edge is where wind gets its first grip. A starter course made from upside-down cut shingles, or left off the rakes, puts the sealant in the wrong place, and the edge is where a roof starts to peel.
Flashing, the covering and the ridge
Flashing is the metal that turns water at every place the roof meets something else. In a valley, where two slopes meet, it is either an open metal valley or a woven or cut valley with a membrane underneath. Along a wall, it is step flashing, one bent piece per course, each one lapped under the shingle above it, with counter-flashing or siding over the top. Around pipes it is a boot.
Most roof leaks start at flashing, not across the open field of the roof. The common shortcuts are reusing old, rusted flashing to save time, replacing step flashing with one long strip and a bead of caulk, and leaving off the kickout at the bottom of a wall that turns water into the gutter. None of it shows from the ground.
The covering is the part you choose: shingle, tile or metal. It is the first line against sun and rain, and its wind rating only holds if it is fastened the way the manufacturer tested it. Nail count, nail placement and starter strips decide that, not the brand name on the bundle.
The ridge cap closes the top of the roof. On a shingle roof it should be purpose-made hip and ridge shingles, not three-tab cut into pieces. Cut three-tab is thinner and cracks when it is bent over the ridge in the sun. On most roofs the ridge cap also sits over the ridge vent, which is where the ventilation comes in.
Ventilation: why the attic has to breathe both ways
An attic needs air coming in low and going out high. Intake is usually through soffit vents under the eaves. Exhaust is usually a ridge vent along the peak, or roof vents near it. Hot air rises and leaves at the top, and cooler air is pulled in at the bottom to replace it. That flow is what keeps the underside of the roof from baking.
The two sides have to be balanced. If there is plenty of exhaust and not enough intake, the exhaust pulls air from wherever it can, including through ceiling gaps from the conditioned house. If the soffits are painted shut or packed with insulation, the attic has nowhere to draw from and runs hot. Mixing exhaust types, like a ridge vent with a powered fan or gable vents, can short-circuit the flow, so one vent pulls air in through the other and the lower attic never moves.
A hot attic cooks the shingles from underneath. The asphalt dries out and the shingle ages faster than the slope next to it with a cooler attic. Many shingle manufacturers write ventilation requirements into their warranty terms, so poor ventilation can also affect a warranty claim. Ask what the manufacturer of your shingle requires.
Ventilation is simple to correct while the roof is open, by cutting in a ridge vent, clearing or adding soffit intake and closing off vents that fight each other. It is much harder afterward. For insurance, we photograph what we find and put the roof's condition in writing. We do not know how your carrier will view any of it. That is between you and your carrier.
