352-830-0756 Serving all of Citrus County Licensed & Insured · FL CCC1333347

Guide

Metal Roof Leak Repair: Where Metal Roofs Actually Leak

A metal roof almost never leaks through the middle of a panel. It leaks at the screws, at the laps, and where the roof meets something else. Here is where to look, what can be fixed in place, and what tells you the panels themselves are finished.

Metal roofingLeak repairFasteners and flashing

The panel is rarely the problem

A sheet of steel or aluminum does not let water through unless it has rusted through or been punctured. On most metal roofs we look at, the panels are still sound. The water gets in where a panel stops, where it joins another panel, or where someone put a hole in it on purpose.

That means the fasteners, the end laps where one panel overlaps the next, the ridge and eave closures, and every flashing around a pipe, vent, skylight or wall. Those parts move and wear, and they depend on rubber, tape or sealant. The steel outlasts all of them.

Before anyone talks about replacing a metal roof for a leak, those details should be checked one by one. Most metal roof leaks start there, and most of them can be fixed there.

A metal roof leaks where the panel stops, joins or has a hole put in it on purpose. The steel itself is usually the last thing to go.

Exposed-fastener roofs and the screw problem

On an exposed-fastener roof, screws go through the face of the panel. This is the ribbed panel you see on Florida homes, sheds and porches. Each screw has a neoprene or EPDM washer under its head. That washer is the seal. When the washer fails, the hole leaks.

Screws fail in two ways. Some back out. The panel expands in the afternoon sun and contracts when a storm cools it. That happens every day, and over the years it works screws loose until the washer no longer presses on the metal. Others were over-driven the day they went in. The washer gets crushed flat or split, and UV cracks it early. A screw driven crooked, or one that missed the framing, does not hold properly either.

On an older roof, both problems are usually spread across the whole roof. Fixing the few screws above a stain does nothing about the hundreds of others that are the same age and in the same condition. That is why a full re-screw is sometimes the honest repair on a panel roof that has been up for twenty years. Every fastener comes out and a new one goes in, usually one size larger so it bites into fresh wood, with a new washer, driven to the right depth. It is slow work. It fixes the cause, not just the one leak you happened to notice.

Laps, flashings and the transitions

Where one panel overlaps another at the end of a run, the lap is sealed with butyl tape. Butyl stays soft for a long time, but heat and movement wear it out. When it hardens, shrinks or slides, wind can push water up the lap. The water then drips off the end of the upper panel onto the decking. On a low-slope roof this is one of the most common leaks we find.

Pipe flashings and curbs are the other usual suspects. A rubber pipe boot cracks in the sun. Sealant around a skylight curb or a vent pulls away as the metal moves. Wall and chimney flashing that was caulked instead of counter-flashed fails the first time the caulk lets go. None of these are panel problems. They are detail problems, and they get repaired or rebuilt one detail at a time.

Ridge cap and eave closures matter too. Foam closures that have broken down, or were never installed, let wind-driven rain blow under the cap or up under the panel ends. None of this is visible from the ground. Finding a leak on a metal roof means getting on the roof.

Standing seam, oil-canning and galvanic corrosion

A standing-seam roof hides its fasteners. Clips under the raised seams hold the panels down, so there are no screws through the face of the roof to fail. When a standing-seam roof leaks, it is almost always at a penetration, a curb, a wall flashing, the ridge or the end of a panel run. Sometimes it is a seam that was damaged or never closed properly. The repair is usually to that one detail. It needs someone who knows that panel system, because standing-seam parts from different manufacturers do not fit each other.

Oil-canning is the wavy, rippled look you sometimes see across the flat of a standing-seam or wide panel. It comes from stress in the metal and from how the panel was fastened and allowed to move. It is cosmetic. It does not let water in by itself, and it is not a reason to replace a roof. If someone says it is causing a leak, ask them to show you where the water is getting through.

Galvanic corrosion is a real failure, and it is easy to cause. When two different metals touch and water is present, one of them corrodes. Copper pipe or flashing against a galvanized or Galvalume panel will eat a hole where the two meet. So will steel screws in an aluminum roof, or treated lumber left lying on a panel. Runoff from copper does the same damage downhill. The fix is to take the wrong metal off, separate whatever has to stay, and decide whether the damaged panel can be patched or needs replacing.

Sealant over a screw head, and when the panels are done

The bad repair we see most is sealant smeared over a screw head. It looks like a fix, and sometimes it stops a drip for a season. But the leak was the failed washer, and the sealant does not fix the washer. It just covers it. When the sealant cracks at the edge, and it will, water gets underneath and sits against the screw and the hole with no way to dry. That speeds up rust around the fastener. Use it to get through a storm if you have to, and treat it as nothing more than that.

Most metal roof leaks can be repaired in place. That means replacing fasteners, re-taping laps, rebuilding pipe flashings and curbs, replacing closures, and removing or separating a metal that should not be touching the panel. A roof with sound panels and failed details needs a repair, sometimes a large one, not a replacement.

The panels are done when the metal itself is going. Look for rust that has gone through the coating and is scaling or eating holes in the steel, especially at the laps and along the eaves where water sits. Look for screw holes rusted out so wide that a larger screw has nothing to bite. Look for coating worn off across the whole roof, not just in spots, and for panels bent, torn or lifted by wind that no longer sit flat. When those show up across the roof and not just in one area, re-screwing means putting new fasteners into metal that will not hold them. If that is where your roof is, we will tell you.

For insurance, we photograph what we find and put the roof's condition in writing. We do not perform or sign wind mitigation or four-point inspections, because a roofing license does not qualify under Florida Statute 627.711(2). What your carrier makes of your metal roof's condition is between you and your carrier.

Straight answers

Common questions

Why is my metal roof leaking if the panels look fine?

Because metal roofs rarely leak through the panels. Water usually gets in at failed screw washers, at end laps where the butyl tape has worn out, or at pipe boots, curbs, wall flashings and ridge closures. All of those can fail while the steel looks perfect from the ground.

Should I just put sealant over the leaking screws?

Only to get through a storm. The leak is the washer under the screw head, and sealant on top does not fix it. Once the sealant cracks at the edge, it holds water against the fastener and speeds up rust. The real repair is a new screw and washer, or on an older roof, a re-screw of the whole roof.

Is oil-canning on my metal roof a leak?

No. Oil-canning is the wavy look across the flat of a panel, caused by stress in the metal and how it was fastened. It is cosmetic and does not let water in on its own. If someone blames a leak on it, ask them to show you where the water is actually coming through.

Can a metal roof be repaired, or does it need replacing?

Most metal roof leaks can be repaired in place, because the panels are usually still sound. Replacement makes sense when the metal itself has failed across the roof: rust through the coating and into the steel, screw holes rusted out too wide to hold a fastener, or panels bent and lifted by wind. We will tell you which one you have after we have been on your roof, not before.

Where to go next

What we actually do

01

Roof Repair

Cracked and lifted shingles, failed boots and flashing, ridge cap damage, nail pops and exposed fasteners.

View
02

Roof Leak Repair

Ceiling stains, active drips, wet insulation, leaks around vents, skylights and lanai tie-ins.

View
03

Roof Replacement

Architectural shingle, standing-seam metal and tile. Full tear-off, deck inspection, code-compliant rebuild.

View